Reviews provided by Syndetics
Publishers Weekly Review
In this noir YA drama, three privileged cousins and a friend meet each summer on a private island, where they confront first love and staggering losses. Reader Meyers does an excellent job with the main character, Cadence, whose dialogue requires the full range of emotions. At the beginning of the story, Cadence seems like a typical sullen teenager trying to find her place in the world and wondering why her boyfriend doesn't write back to her. As the story continues and grows darker, however, she pieces together her spotty memories of an on-island accident that wrecked her health and distanced her from the family, a whole cast of characters that Meyers also voices. These characters include Cadence's snobby mother and her two shrill, money-grubbing sisters, who spend the bulk of their summers trying to wheedle themselves into their father's good graces and substantial inheritance. Where the narration falls short is with the grandfather, who gets a voice that is stereotypically gruff and shaggy, even in his rare tender moments. Ages 12-up. A Delacorte hardcover. (May) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
School Library Journal Review
Gr 7 Up-Cadence Sinclair Easton has spent all of her summers on her family's private island, Beechwood, with three generations of family, including her cousins Johnny and Mirren, and a family friend, Gat, an Indian boy. The novel begins during what Cadence and her peers label "summer 15." They refer to themselves as "the liars" and enjoy the typical teen activities, according to Cadence, who narrates. But during summer 15, two important events occur at Beechwood. Cadence and Gat fall in love and Cadence suffers an accident that causes her severe migraine headaches and loss of memory. This accident eventually causes Cadence to stay away from Beechwood and her cousins for a year while she recuperates. It becomes clear as Cadence tells her story that she is emotionally fragile and unreliable, and that she has moments where she remembers secrets and lies. Ariadne Meyers performs here and does an excellent job of portraying the troubled teen. Listeners will definitely be able to absorb the essence of Cadence's mental anguish as well as the emotions of each of the various characters in this multigenerational family drama. Fans of Gillian Flynn will probably want to add this to their list of must-reads. The story saves its biggest punch for the end, and listeners will not see the twist coming.-Sheila Acosta, San Antonio Public Library, TX (c) Copyright 2012. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Booklist Review
*Starred Review* Cadence Sinclair Eastman is the oldest grandchild of a preeminent family. The Sinclairs have the height, the blondness, and the money to distinguish them, as well as a private island off the coast of Massachusetts called Beechwood. Harris, the family patriarch, has three daughters: Bess, Carrie, and Penny, who is Cadence's mother. And then there is the next generation, the Liars : Cadence; Johnny, the first grandson; Mirren, sweet and curious; and outsider Gat, an Indian boy and the nephew of Carrie's boyfriend. Cadence, Johnny, Mirren, and Gat are a unit, especially during summer 15, the phrase they use to mark their fifteenth year on Beechwood the summer that Cady and Gat fall in love. When Lockhart's mysterious, haunting novel opens, readers learn that Cady, during this summer, has been involved in a mysterious accident, in which she sustained a blow to the head, and now suffers from debilitating migraines and memory loss. She doesn't return to Beechwood until summer 17, when she recovers snippets of memory, and secrets and lies as well as issues of guilt and blame, love and truth all come into play. Throughout the narrative, Lockhart weaves in additional fairy tales, mostly about three beautiful daughters, a king, and misfortune. Surprising, thrilling, and beautifully executed in spare, precise, and lyrical prose, Lockhart spins a tragic family drama, the roots of which go back generations. And the ending? Shhhh. Not telling. (But it's a doozy). HIGH-DEMAND BACKSTORY: Lockhart's latest is unlike anything she's done before. With a Printz Honor to back her, plus a major marketing campaign and a promotional quote from John Green this is poised to be big.--Kelley, Ann Copyright 2010 Booklist
Horn Book Review
After a two-year absence due to an accident she can't remember, seventeen-year-old Cady Sinclair Eastman returns to the private island where the beautiful, entitled Sinclair clan spends its summers. Relationships (particularly among Cady, her same-age cousins Johnny and Mirren, and family friend Gat; and among her mother and aunts) feel oddly strained, and no one will tell Cady what happened the summer of the accident. The pieces of her fragmented memory slowly come together to reveal a truth more devastating than Cady (or the listener) could have imagined. Meyers gives the first-person narrative a vulnerability perfectly suited to damaged, self-deluded Cady while also, in flashbacks, evoking the carefree days of previous summers. This novel's shocking denouement hits hard -- and even more so when related with Meyers's disbelieving, heartbroken delivery. katie bircher (c) Copyright 2014. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.